In India’s parliamentary structure, the Rajya Sabha is often considered a secondary chamber. Critically examine.
Answer: The Rajya Sabha, the Upper House of India’s Parliament, was established to represent states in the federal structure and to act as a revising chamber. However, its limited role in financial matters and executive accountability often leads to its perception as “secondary.”
Reasons behind Rajya Sabha being Considered a ‘Secondary House’
- Money and Financial Bills: It cannot introduce or amend a Money Bill and can only make recommendations. Example: The Aadhaar Act was passed as a Money Bill, bypassing the Rajya Sabha.
- No-confidence Motion: The Council of Ministers cannot be dismissed by it, as they are answerable only ....
Do You Want to Read More?
Subscribe Now
Take Annual Subscription and get the following Advantage
The annual members of the Civil Services Chronicle can read the monthly content of the magazine as well as the Chronicle magazine archives.
Readers can study all the material before the last six months of the Civil Services Chronicle monthly issue in the form of Chronicle magazine archives.
Related Content
- 1 ‘Empathy’ and ‘compassion’ are foundational values for addressing significant issues and for decision-making in administration. Suggest mechanisms through which these values can be developed in the civil services. Provide relevant examples.
- 2 An independent and robust social audit mechanism is essential for ensuring performance, accountability, and ethical conduct in the public service sector. Discuss.
- 3 "Ethics involves several key dimensions that are crucial for guiding the moral behaviour of individuals and organizations." Explain the key dimensions of ethics that influence human action. Discuss how these dimensions shape ethical decision-making.
- 4 Discuss how the lack of integrity and objectivity in civil servants can negatively impact the quality of governance.
- 5 "Attitude is not static; rather, it evolves with time and experiences.” Discuss.
- 6 Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) play a significant role in India's economic development. Critically evaluate the importance of the MSME sector.
- 7 Discuss the multifaceted factors affecting resource mobilization in India, and discuss measures to enhance the efficiency and efficacy of the resource mobilization mechanism.
- 8 Vulnerability mapping is a critical tool for disaster risk reduction. Explain its components and methodologies. How can it be integrated with other spatial planning tools for effective disaster management?
- 9 "The integration of paramilitary forces with local law enforcement agencies is crucial for effective border management." Discuss.
- 10 Discuss how India's growing reliance on cloud computing services presents new cybersecurity challenges. Propose a comprehensive strategy to mitigate these risks.
UPSC
- 1 Political apathy among citizens weakens democratic institutions and accountability. Discuss the ethical dimensions of political apathy and suggest measures to promote responsible civic participation.
- 2 A constructive attitude is crucial for public servants dealing with complex challenges and high-pressure situations. What factors contribute to developing such an attitude in individuals?
- 3 “The consequences of moral actions may not be immediate, but they are enduring.” Explain this statement with examples.
- 4 “Punishing corruption without addressing the mindset behind it is a short-term fix.” How can a shift in attitudes among public servants and citizens contribute to long-term anti-corruption efforts?
- 5 Reports of deepfake videos and AI-generated misinformation are steadily rising in India, often resulting in reputational harm and mental distress. In light of such developments, what are the ethical dimensions of human behaviour in the digital world? How can families and educational institutions contribute to fostering digital responsibility and empathy among youth?
- 6 The Government of India recently stated that “The end of Left-Wing Extremism has begun.” In this context, examine the broader strategy behind India’s special campaign to eliminate Naxalism by 2026.
- 7 How can the AgriStack initiative contribute to increasing agricultural productivity and income in India? What concerns have emerged regarding its implementation?
- 8 “India’s air defence system stands as a multi-layered, technologically sophisticated framework that shields the nation from diverse aerial threats.” Explain.
- 9 "Emerging technologies offer transformative capabilities in border management, but also pose operational challenges." Analyze this statement in the context of India’s efforts to modernize its border infrastructure and surveillance capabilities.
- 10 What is Flexible Inflation Targeting (FIT)? In the context of India’s emerging macroeconomic scenario, evaluate its effectiveness in achieving its stated objectives.
- 11 Highlight the constitutional and legal provisions governing the Delimitation Commission in India and discuss why the upcoming delimitation exercise has raised concerns in southern states.
- 12 In the Indian parliamentary system, Department-Related Standing Committees (DRSCs) are often called 'mini-parliaments.' Examine.
- 13 The Small Island Developing States (SIDS) of the Indian Ocean are not only vulnerable regions but also strategic partners in India’s Indo-Pacific vision. Discuss.
- 14 Digital access has become the 'new gateway' to participatory democracy in India. In this context, how does the 2025 Supreme Court judgment declaring digital access as a fundamental right strengthen participatory democracy? Explain with suitable examples.
- 15 Mental health challenges among youth in India are not just personal struggles but indicators of systemic developmental gaps. Examine.
- 16 The concept of "Sponge Cities" is gaining attention in urban areas. Discuss this in the context of ecological stress caused by unplanned urbanisation in India.
- 17 In India, fertility rate has fallen below replacement level. Analyse the implications of this in the context of India’s demographic transition.
- 18 While regionalism in India has often served as a medium for cultural assertion and developmental demands, it can also pose challenges to national integration. Analyse.
- 19 Discuss the mythological significance of the Chakra symbol in Indian traditions.
