In India’s parliamentary structure, the Rajya Sabha is often considered a secondary chamber. Critically examine.
Answer: The Rajya Sabha, the Upper House of India’s Parliament, was established to represent states in the federal structure and to act as a revising chamber. However, its limited role in financial matters and executive accountability often leads to its perception as “secondary.”
Reasons behind Rajya Sabha being Considered a ‘Secondary House’
- Money and Financial Bills: It cannot introduce or amend a Money Bill and can only make recommendations. Example: The Aadhaar Act was passed as a Money Bill, bypassing the Rajya Sabha.
- No-confidence Motion: The Council of Ministers cannot be dismissed by it, as they are answerable only ....
Do You Want to Read More?
Subscribe Now
To get access to detailed content
Already a Member? Login here
Take Annual Subscription and get the following Advantage
The annual members of the Civil Services Chronicle can read the monthly content of the magazine as well as the Chronicle magazine archives.
Readers can study all the material since 2018 of the Civil Services Chronicle monthly issue in the form of Chronicle magazine archives.
UPSC
- 1 Political apathy among citizens weakens democratic institutions and accountability. Discuss the ethical dimensions of political apathy and suggest measures to promote responsible civic participation.
- 2 What is Flexible Inflation Targeting (FIT)? In the context of India’s emerging macroeconomic scenario, evaluate its effectiveness in achieving its stated objectives.
- 3 Highlight the constitutional and legal provisions governing the Delimitation Commission in India and discuss why the upcoming delimitation exercise has raised concerns in southern states.
- 4 In the Indian parliamentary system, Department-Related Standing Committees (DRSCs) are often called 'mini-parliaments.' Examine.
- 5 The Small Island Developing States (SIDS) of the Indian Ocean are not only vulnerable regions but also strategic partners in India’s Indo-Pacific vision. Discuss.
- 6 Digital access has become the 'new gateway' to participatory democracy in India. In this context, how does the 2025 Supreme Court judgment declaring digital access as a fundamental right strengthen participatory democracy? Explain with suitable examples.
- 7 Mental health challenges among youth in India are not just personal struggles but indicators of systemic developmental gaps. Examine.
- 8 The concept of "Sponge Cities" is gaining attention in urban areas. Discuss this in the context of ecological stress caused by unplanned urbanisation in India.
- 9 In India, fertility rate has fallen below replacement level. Analyse the implications of this in the context of India’s demographic transition.
- 10 While regionalism in India has often served as a medium for cultural assertion and developmental demands, it can also pose challenges to national integration. Analyse.
