Current News National
ISRO's Chandrayaan 1 Spots Rusting On The Moon
- By studying data from the Chandrayaan-1's Moon Mineralogy Mapper instrument (M3) built by the National Aeronautics Space Administration’s (NASA) Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), scientists think that the Moon may be rusting along the poles.
- The occurrence of rust is a riddle because even though the Moon is known to have iron-rich rocks littered across the surface, it’s not known for the presence of water and oxygen — two elements that need to interact with iron to create rust.
Explanation by the Researchers
- Researchers at the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) believe that this could because Earth’s own atmosphere.
Role of Earth’s Atmosphere
The Puzzle of Oxygen
- The Moon is constantly bombarded by solar particles coming off the Sun. Without an atmosphere to protect itself, the hydrogen should make it difficult for rust to form because Hydrogen is a reducer, it adds electrons to the material it touches. For iron to rust, it needs the opposite — an oxidiser which removes electrons instead.
- Earth’s magnetotail — the part of its magnetic atmosphere that extends away from the Sun — is capable of blocking out 99% of the solar wind aimed at the Moon when it’s in its Full Moon phase.
- That part of the lunar cycle gives iron on the Moon occasional windows of opportunity for rust to form.
- Earth’s magnetotail does more than just provide the Moon with a shield. During that interaction, some of the oxygen from the planet also gets transferred over. This was confirmed by Japan’s Kaguya orbiter in 2007.
- So, even though the Moon isn’t rich in oxygen, it does have access to oxygen during the same window of opportunity when it’s not being bombarded with hydrogen.
The Puzzle of Water
- Even though the rest of the Moon is bone dry, its poles have long been suspected of hosting water. Albeit only in shadowed craters located on the far side of the Moon — far from where the rust has been detected.
- Researchers propose that fast-moving dust particles, which regularly pelt the Moon, could release surface-borne water molecules and mix them with iron in the lunar soil. Compounding the interaction, the resulting heat from these impacts could increase the oxidation rate.
So if all three ingredients are in place — a Full Moon phase, water molecules and oxygen travelling from Earth — the perfect storm to create rust can in fact occur.
Questions still left Unanswered
- Exactly how water is interacting with lunar rocks.
- Why rusting is occurring on the far side of the moon, where it’s blocked off from Earth’s oxygen.
Current News National
Vinod Yadav: First CEO Of Restructured Railway Board
- The Appointments Committee of the Cabinet has approved the appointment of the current chairman of the Railway Board V K Yadav as the first ever Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the organisation as part of the government decision to restructure the Railway Board.
- The corporatisation plan was part of a proposal cleared by the Cabinet in December 2019 for making the 115-year-old board leaner by cutting its strength from eight to five.
The Reconstituted Board
- The board will now be headed by Yadav as chairman and CEO, and will have four others — Pradeep Kumar as member (infrastructure), P C Sharma as member (traction and rolling stock), P S Mishra as member (operations and business development), and ManjulaRangarajan as member (finance).
Other Notable Changes
IRHS: The Indian Railway Medical Service (IRMS) will be renamed the Indian Railway Health Service (IRHS).
IRMS: The process to merge eight railway-related wings into a single central service called the Indian Railway Management Service (IRMS) is underway.
Various Committees for Reforming Railways
- The unification of services had earlier been mooted by various committees for reforming Railways including - the Prakash Tandon Committee (1994), Rakesh Mohan Committee (2001), Sam Pitroda Committee (2012) and Bibek Debroy Committee (2015).
Benefits of this Move
- The restructuring will be a zero-cost exercise. Money will be saved because of the surrendered board posts, and by stopping duplication of works.
Current News National
Draft Data Empowerment And Protection Architecture (DEPA)
- The government of India’s policy think-tank NITI Aayog has released a draft for Data Empowerment and Protection Architecture (DEPA) draft for public consultation in order to seek opinion on the implementation of the framework, which is set to launch by 2020-end.
- To empower individuals to control how their personal and financial data is used and shared.
- To democratise access and enable portability of trusted financial and other data between service providers or other third-party institutions.
Provision of Consent Managers
- The proposed framework has recommended setting up a ‘Consent Manager’ institution, which will ensure that individuals can provide their consent as per an innovative digital standard. These consent managers will also be responsible for protecting users’ data rights.
- Consent Manager can plug in to a network of information providers and users without setting up expensive, duplicative, and exclusive bilateral data sharing rails. And it ensures that data sharing occurs by default with granular, revocable, auditable, and secure consent.
- These consent managers can compete to reach different customer segments with accessible and inclusive modes of obtaining consent. They will also be free to experiment with different business models.
DEPA to Boost Entrepreneurship, Financial Inclusion
- DEPA would allow these MSMEs to get a digital footprint, which in turn, would enable them to access capital and other benefits like insurance and better financial management products. Even individual, without any digital footprint so far, will be able to access these benefits.
Current Initiatives towards DEPA
- The government is currently running a pilot of DEPA in the health sector. The development comes after Prime Minister Narendra Modi, on August 15, launched the tech-based National Digital Health Mission (NDHM) to revolutionise the Indian health sector. It will pitch a more centralised and data-driven health sector that will work on the Aadhar-like model to share all confidential medical data such as prescriptions, diagnostic reports, discharge summaries and more.
- Next in line is the telecom sector, following TRAI consultation report on privacy released in July 2018 and a workshop held by TRAI Chairman RS Sharma in August 2020 with industry players.
Why we need DEPA?
- Lending companies use a host of mechanisms to obtain data about users from different sources and in particular, online lending companies acquire a lot of digital data about users from other financial service providers before underwriting loans. Health insurance companies need to obtain hospitalization and diagnostic data about patients for them to be able to make insurance payments and this data is shared by hospitals and labs, often in digital form, with such companies.
- In these applications, it is essential that users provide consent to the service provider sharing data (the data provider) before they share data with the provider requesting access (the data consumer). It is also essential that privacy of the data be safeguarded i.e. to ensure the data is accessible only by the data consumer, only for a stipulated amount of time and only for a stipulated purpose, as consented to by the user. It is also desirable that all data sharing transactions be traceable and auditable in the future. Finally, the data sharing process itself should be easy, efficient and user-friendly.
Current News Ecology & Environment Pollution
UN Experts Flag Concerns On EIA Notification
- Recently, a group of Special Rapporteurs to the United Nations has written to the Centre expressing concern over the proposed Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) notification 2020.
- It has sought the government’s response on how the provisions of the notification were consonant with India’s “obligations under international law”.
Vital Concerns raised by UN Special Rapporteurs
- Under the Clauses 14 (2) and 26, the notification provide an exemption to a number of giant industries such as chemical manufacturing and petroleum merchandise, constructing, widening of nationwide highways, etc. from public consultation — as part of the environment impact assessment process.
- The rapporteurs argued that the exemptions were unwarranted, particularly when there was a serious gas leak from (LG Polymers) chemical plant in Visakhapatnam on May 12, 2020 and oil gas blowout in Assam’s Dibrugarh in June, 2020.
- The draft notification doesn’t require publication of data or holding of public session for tasks labelled by the Central authorities as ‘involving strategic concerns’.
- There is clause on “post-facto clearance” is worrisome. These are forprojects which began without acquiring the required environmental clearances or permissions.
- Overall, it contradicts fundamental ideas associated to the environmental rule of regulationthat obstructed people’s rights to a safe, clean and healthy environment.
Indian Government’s Response over the Concerns
- The government said that nothing in the proposed EIA, 2020 violated the UN Declaration of Human Rights and that the rapporteur’s concerns were “misplaced”.
- The proposed EIA is still a draft and issued for public consultation and that there were several imperfections in the existing EIA that were to be amended in the new notification.
- With regard to post-facto clearances, the violation of not taking prior approval would be punished as per law and projects that were already running would be considered only on merit.
UN Special Rapporteurs
Furore over Draft Environment Impact Assessment Notification, 2020
The draft Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) notification 2020 proposed by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change has met with massive opposition.
Contentious Clauses in Draft EIA, 2020
- Re-Categorisation of Projects: It re-categorises all the projects and activities related to the production of bulk drugs and intermediates for several ailments from ‘A’ category to ‘B2’ category.This re-categorisationwill seriously affect the environment, since these will be carried out without oversight.
- Post-facto Approval: The new draft allows for post-facto approval for projects. It means that the clearances for projects can be awarded even if they have started construction or have been running phase without securing environmental clearances.It implies that those projects can also seek clearance that violate the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 (EPA).
- Reducing Public Participation: Numerous provisions of the new EIA also endanger the basic tenets of public participation. The period for public consultation has been reduced from 30 days to 20 days. Considering the socio-political context of the vulnerable population typically affected by ‘development’ projects, this reduction could literally exclude some groups of people from consultation.
- Exemption of Strategic Projects: The introduction of the category of “strategic projects’’, which has been clubbed with Defence projects, has also been a cause of concern — they do not require public consultation, and information need not to be made public.These points to excessive executive discretion.
- Compliance Report Issue: The 2006 EIA required that the project proponent submit a report every six months, showing that they are carrying out their activities as per the terms on which permission has been given.However, the new draft requires the promoter to submit a report only once every year.During this period, certain irreversible environmental, social or health consequences of the project could go unnoticed because of the extended reporting time.
- Exemption to Construction Projects up to 150,000 sq m: It also exempts up to 150,000 sq m construction projects from the assessment. These projects can now gain environment clearance after scrutiny by state-level expert appraisal committee. Earlier, the exemption was granted to construction projects of up to 20,000 sq. m or above.
- Though established to safeguard the environment, the EIA process, argue activists, often achieved the opposite by offering a facade of legal paperwork for a range of de facto concessions enjoyed by industries.
- For example, reports on project’s potential (damaging) impact on the environment — the bedrock of the EIA process — are frequently shoddy and consultant agencies that prepare those reports for a fee are rarely held accountable.
- Lack of administrative capacity to ensure compliance often renders long lists of clearance conditions meaningless.
- On the other hand, developers complain that the EIA regime dampened the spirit of liberalisation, leading to red tape and rent-seeking. Delay in project clearance during the UPA-II rule became an election issue in 2014 when then prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi hit out at the Congress by claiming that files did not move in the Environment Ministry till “Jayanthi tax” was paid.
- The 2020 draft offers no remedy for the political and bureaucratic stronghold on the EIA process, and thereby on industries. Instead, it proposes to bolster the government’s discretionary power while limiting public engagement in safeguarding the environment.
- The government’s actions on environmental regulation (as opposed to its bon mots and rhetoric) show that it considers it an impediment to the ease of doing business.
- India is a party to the Rio declaration adopted by the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) in 1992, which enunciated a catalogue of environmental principles including sustainable development, precautionary principle, and EIA.
- India is also party to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) and United Nations Framework on Climate Change (UNFCCC), which contain a requirement to have a prior EIA in situations having a significant threat to the environment.
- Weakening the EIA process is essentially anti-democratic. For affected communities, where seismic shifts in the local environment can threaten livelihoods, flood a valley or destroy a forest, public consultation is a referendum on existential threats.
- The Environment Ministry must make sure that the final EIA draft does justice to the complex relations between environment, development and local communities that the public consultation process has brought to light.
- The dilution of environmental standards in the EIA needs to be evaluated in the background of the robust environmental principles operating at the national and international levels.
- Also, decisions that will lock-in carbon-intensive infrastructure in the long term need to be scrutinised, particularly in light of India’s commitments under the Paris Agreement process.
- The Environment Ministry needs to be clear about its role — its mandate is to create and sustain a regulatory framework that prevents the plunder of our natural resources, not actively accelerate the pace of environmental devastation.
- As India is a highly vulnerable country, it should be the government’s priority to ensure that regulatory approvals do not make parts of the country more vulnerable or adversely impact the adaptive capabilities of communities.
Environmental Impact Assessment(EIA)