PM Expresses Solidarity with Israel amidst Conflict

  • 09 Oct 2023

On 7th October, 2023, India’s Prime Minister extended his support to Israel as Hamas launched land, sea, and air attacks from the Gaza Strip.

Key Points

  • PM Modi's Solidarity: Thousands of rockets from Gaza hit southern and central Israel, prompting Mr. Modi's message of support for the nation.
  • Embassy's Safety Advisory: The Indian Embassy in Tel Aviv, Israel, has issued safety guidelines for Indian nationals.
  • India and Israel share close relations in areas such as security, defence, and technology.
  • Challenges of Religious Tourism: Israel is a significant destination for global religious tourism, hosting biblical and Muslim holy sites.
  • Indian pilgrims often navigate through territories and checkpoints controlled by both Israeli and Palestinian authorities.
  • Safety Concerns for Bnei Menashe: Israel has a significant population of Bnei Menashe members from India's northeastern region, who were granted Israeli citizenship under a special scheme.
  • Air India Flight Cancellation: Due to the ongoing conflict and active conflict zone airspace over Israel, Air India's New Delhi-Tel Aviv flight has been canceled.

Israel-Palestine Conflict Overview

  • The Israel-Palestine conflict is a long-standing dispute rooted in historical claims to identity and land, with Jerusalem at its epicentre.
  • 1948 Arab-Israel War: In the initial Arab-Israeli war of 1948, Israel seized the western part of Jerusalem, while Jordan occupied the eastern part, which was later captured and annexed by Israel.
  • East Jerusalem Settlements: Since then, Israel has expanded its settlements in East Jerusalem. The Palestinians aspire to establish East Jerusalem as the capital of their future state.
  • Differing Perspectives: Israel regards Jerusalem as its unified and eternal capital, while Palestinian leadership insists on East Jerusalem's recognition as the capital of their envisioned state, resisting any compromise.
  • Sheikh Jarrah Eviction Threat: Palestinians in the Sheikh Jarrah neighbourhood of East Jerusalem face the risk of eviction, with their land slated for transfer to Jewish settlers.
  • Al-Aqsa Mosque Tensions: Recent Israeli military actions, including the assault on the Al-Aqsa Mosque, the third holiest site in Islam, ahead of a Zionist nationalist march, triggered widespread concern among followers and calls for its defence by radicals.
  • Hamas and Recent Tensions: Hamas, the largest Palestinian militant Islamist group, was formed in 1988 during the first Palestinian intifada.
  • It is committed to the destruction of Israel and carries out both armed resistance and social welfare programs.

Factors Influencing Hamas's Massive Incursion into Israel

Deepening Occupation and Escalating Violence

  • The Israel-Palestine relationship has seen a continuous deterioration.
  • Israel conducts frequent military operations in the occupied West Bank, escalating the tensions.
  • The year has witnessed significant casualties on both sides, with Israeli raids in Jenin and a raid on Jerusalem's Al Aqsa Mosque compound, followed by rocket attacks from Gaza and Israeli airstrikes.
  • This consistent violence and lack of a peace process have fuelled anger among Palestinians, both against Israeli occupation and the Palestinian Authority.

Hamas Capitalizing on Public Anger

  • Hamas's massive attack from Gaza, calling on all Palestinians, including Israeli Arab citizens, to take up arms against Israel, aims to leverage this public anger against occupation
  • It seeks to position itself as the primary advocate for the Palestinian cause amid the absence of a viable peace process.

Divisions in Israeli Society

  • Israel is undergoing internal challenges with its right-wing government attempting to consolidate power.
  • Efforts to curtail the judiciary's authority have triggered protests, including participation from military reservists.
  • This internal division may have led Hamas to perceive Israel as vulnerable, providing an opportunity to launch a significant attack from Gaza and potentially incite more resistance violence in the West Bank.

Geopolitical Considerations

  • Hamas's attack coincides with advanced normalization talks between Israel and Saudi Arabia.
  • Saudi Crown Prince’s remarks about progress in these talks indicate shifting dynamics in the region.
  • Such normalization could affect Hamas's position adversely, particularly as Saudi Arabia is a significant player in the Arab world.
  • This development may not align with the interests of Iran and Lebanon's Hezbollah, both of which support Hamas and Islamic Jihad.
  • They welcomed the Hamas operation, potentially complicating the prospects for an immediate Saudi-Israel normalization deal.